Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Enter the home and the rent. Both options cost money each month, and whichever costs less invests the difference. You will see who ends up ahead, and when buying catches up.

Last reviewed

Buying
$
$
%
years
%
%
%
%
$
$
%
Renting
$
%
$
Your money
%
years

After 10 years

Renting by $11,013

buying stays ahead from year 13

Net worth if you buy
$234,029
Net worth if you rent
$245,042
Owning, month one
$2,881
Renting, month one
$2,217

Net worth means the home’s value, less selling costs and the mortgage, plus anything invested. Whoever pays less each month invests the difference, so both spend the same in total. Taxes are not included.

How long you stay
YearsResult
1Renting ahead by $35,012
3Renting ahead by $32,217
5Renting ahead by $28,166
7Renting ahead by $22,639
10Renting ahead by $11,013
15Buying ahead by $19,914
20Buying ahead by $70,877
30Buying ahead by $271,393
If home prices grow by…
0% a yearRenting ahead by $124,723
2% a yearRenting ahead by $52,519
3% a yearRenting ahead by $11,013
5% a yearBuying ahead by $84,349
If rent is…
$1,540 a monthRenting ahead by $133,216
$1,760 a monthRenting ahead by $92,482
$2,200 a monthRenting ahead by $11,013
$2,640 a monthBuying ahead by $70,455
$3,080 a monthBuying ahead by $151,924
If investments earn…
0% a yearBuying ahead by $88,079
4% a yearBuying ahead by $28,275
6% a yearRenting ahead by $11,013
8% a yearRenting ahead by $58,314

The mistake in most rent-versus-buy comparisons

The usual comparison puts a monthly rent beside a monthly mortgage payment and declares a winner. It is wrong in both directions.

Rent is a lot less than the real cost of owning. Owning also costs property tax, insurance and upkeep, and you spend a large lump sum, the down payment and closing costs, before you start. But renting is not free of consequences either: rent rises every year, and you own nothing at the end.

The fair comparison is net worth: after a given number of years, who has more?

How the comparison works

Both choices cost money each month, and the money you do not spend on one choice is still yours to invest. So:

  • The buyer spends the down payment and closing costs up front, then pays the mortgage, property tax, insurance and upkeep.
  • The renter invests that same lump sum, then pays rent.
  • Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference. That way both spend the same in total, and neither side gets a free advantage.

At the end, the buyer’s net worth is the home’s value, less selling costs and the mortgage still owed, plus any investments. The renter’s is the investments.

An example

A $400,000 home with $80,000 down at 6.5% over 30 years. Closing costs are 3%, property tax 1.2% a year, insurance $1,500, upkeep 1% of the home’s value a year. Prices rise 3% a year. Against that, rent of $2,200 rising 3% a year, plus $200 of renter’s insurance. Invested money earns 6%.

  • The mortgage payment is $2,022.62
  • Owning costs $2,880.95 in month one, tax, insurance and upkeep take it far above the loan payment
  • Renting costs $2,216.67

The buyer pays about $664 a month more to start with. After ten years:

Net worth
Buying $234,029
Renting $245,042

Renting is ahead by $11,013. Over those ten years the owner paid $358,596 on the home, including $193,998 of mortgage interest, against $304,646 of rent. The home is worth $537,567 and $271,284 is still owed.

Buying catches up slowly

The gap closes every year, because the loan is being paid down and the home is rising in value:

Years you stay Result
1 Renting ahead by $35,012
3 Renting ahead by $32,217
5 Renting ahead by $28,166
7 Renting ahead by $22,639
10 Renting ahead by $11,013
15 Buying ahead by $19,914
20 Buying ahead by $70,877
30 Buying ahead by $271,393

On these figures, year 13 is where buying pulls ahead and stays there. Stay a year or two and renting wins by $35,000, because the costs of buying and selling are lost the moment you move.

That is the most important number in this decision: how long you will really stay.

What changes the answer

Three assumptions decide the result, and nobody knows any of them.

How fast home prices rise. After ten years:

Price growth Result
0% a year Renting ahead by $124,723
2% Renting ahead by $52,519
3% Renting ahead by $11,013
5% Buying ahead by $84,349

At 0% growth, buying does not break even until year 30. At 5% it breaks even in year 4.

How much rent costs. The same home, different rents:

Rent Result after ten years
$1,540 Renting ahead by $133,216
$1,760 Renting ahead by $92,482
$2,200 Renting ahead by $11,013
$2,640 Buying ahead by $70,455
$3,080 Buying ahead by $151,924

What your savings earn. If the renter’s invested money earns 0% rather than 6%, buying is ahead by $88,079; at 8% renting is ahead by $58,314. The better your alternatives for your money, the better renting looks.

The mortgage rate matters more than people expect

Mortgage rate Result after ten years
5% Buying ahead by $49,924
6.5% Renting ahead by $11,013
8% Renting ahead by $73,780

A swing of 1.5 points either way is worth about $60,000 over ten years, and flips the answer.

A cash buyer

Paying $400,000 in cash removes the mortgage and its interest. Buying is then ahead by $9,529 after ten years, from year 9. It also ties up the whole $400,000, which is why most people do not choose it.

What this does not capture

  • Tax. The mortgage interest deduction, tax on investment gains and the tax rules on selling a home are not included. They vary and can matter.
  • Flexibility. Renting is easy to leave. Owning is not. That has value this calculator cannot price.
  • Risk. A home is one concentrated asset. Investments can be spread.
  • Steady assumptions. Prices and rents do not rise at fixed rates. Treat the tables as a range, not a forecast.
  • Non-financial reasons. Stability, space to change, and the pleasure of owning a home are real reasons to buy even when the money says otherwise.

If you decide to buy, the house affordability calculator shows what a lender may allow, and the mortgage calculator gives the full schedule.

How it is calculated

Month by month. The buyer’s cost is the mortgage payment (while the loan lasts) plus a twelfth of property tax and upkeep on the home’s value that year, plus insurance and any dues. The renter’s cost is the rent that year, plus insurance. The lump sum starts in the renter’s pot; each month, the pot of whoever pays less receives the difference, and every pot grows at a twelfth of the annual return. The home’s value rises once a year. The break-even is the first year from which buying never falls behind again.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy?

It depends on how long you stay, how fast prices and rents rise, and what your savings would earn. On the reference case, a $400,000 home against $2,200 rent, renting is ahead by $11,013 after ten years and buying is ahead by $19,914 after fifteen. No answer is right for everyone, which is why the calculator shows how each assumption moves it.

How does the calculator compare them fairly?

By net worth. The buyer starts by spending the down payment and closing costs and pays a larger monthly bill; the renter invests that lump sum. Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference at the same return, so both spend the same in total. At the end, the buyer's net worth is the home's value less selling costs and the mortgage, plus investments, and the renter's is the investments.

What is the break-even point?

The first year from which buying stays ahead. On the reference case it is year 13. It moves a lot: with 5% yearly price growth it is year 4, and with 0% it is year 30. The break-even is short when prices are rising, rents are high or mortgage rates are low.

Why do closing and selling costs matter so much?

Because they are lost every time you move. On a $400,000 home, 3% to buy is $12,000 and 6% to sell is about $24,000 or more. Those must be recovered before buying pulls ahead, which is why short stays so often favour renting.

Does it include taxes?

No. It leaves out the mortgage interest deduction, tax on investment gains and the tax rules on selling a home, which vary by country and situation. Property tax and upkeep are included as costs. Check the IRS or your own tax authority on the sale of a home.

What assumptions should I test?

Home price growth, rent growth and the investment return are the three that decide it, and nobody knows them. The tables on this page show the result at several values of each. If the answer flips within the range you think is plausible, the decision is close, and non-financial reasons such as stability or flexibility matter more.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.