Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Refinance Calculator: Break-Even on Any Loan

Enter your current balance, your rate and the months left, then the new offer and the closing costs. You will see the month you break even, how much you are ahead for however long you stay, and the cost of a longer term. If you only know your original mortgage, the mortgage refinance calculator starts from that instead.

Last reviewed

Your current loan
$
%
The new loan
%
$
years

You break even in month

15

about 1y 3m, stay longer and you are ahead

Monthly payment
$1,847 → $1,611
Saved each month
$236.73
If you stay 5 yr
+$14,205
Over the whole loan
+$66,515
KeepRefinance
Monthly payment$1,847.48$1,610.75
Payments left300300
Interest still to pay$304,242$233,227
Total still to pay$554,242$487,727
How much ahead you are, by how long you stay
StayRefinancing leaves you
1 year−$749 behind
2 years$3,002 ahead
3 years$6,748 ahead
5 years$14,205 ahead
7 years$21,573 ahead
10 years$32,321 ahead
15 years$48,664 ahead

The rule of thumb, closing costs ÷ monthly saving, gives 19.0 months. The figure above is earlier because a lower rate also pays your balance down faster.

The only question that matters: how long will you keep the loan?

Refinancing swaps your loan for a new one, usually at a lower rate, and charges you for the swap. The saving arrives slowly, month by month. The cost arrives on day one. So the decision comes down to one comparison: will you keep the loan long enough for the savings to overtake the cost?

Take $250,000 owed at 7.5%, with 25 years (300 months) left. You can refinance to 6.0% over the same 300 months, for $4,500 of closing costs paid up front.

  • Your payment falls from $1,847.48 to $1,610.75: $236.73 a month
  • You break even in month 15
  • Keep the loan for the full term and you are $66,514.97 better off

Those are three different answers to “is it worth it?”, and the right one depends on your plans.

What staying put is worth

The longer you stay, the more refinancing is ahead. For the loan above:

If you keep the loan for Refinancing leaves you
1 year $748.98 behind
2 years $3,001.71 ahead
3 years $6,747.67 ahead
5 years $14,204.58 ahead
7 years $21,573.16 ahead
10 years $32,320.52 ahead
15 years $48,663.96 ahead
the full 25 years $66,514.97 ahead

Sell or move in year one and you lose $749. Stay five years and you gain $14,205. The calculator lets you set how long you expect to keep the loan, and shows this table for your own figures.

Two ways to count the break-even

The usual rule of thumb divides the closing costs by the monthly saving: $4,500 ÷ $236.73 = 19.01 months.

The calculator reports month 15 instead, and the difference is real. The rule of thumb counts only the lower payment. But a lower rate also means more of each payment goes to principal, so by month 15 you owe less than you would have under the old loan. The calculator compares, at each month, what you would have paid plus what you would still owe, with and without the refinance, and reports the first month you are ahead.

For a small saving the gap widens. Refinance from 7.5% to 7.0% and the rule of thumb says 55.88 months; the full comparison says 44.

A small rate cut is a poor deal

The break-even depends hard on how far the rate falls. Same $250,000, same $4,500 of costs, same 300-month term:

New rate New payment Saved each month Break-even Saved over the loan
7.25% $1,807.02 $40.46 month 87 $7,638.76
7.0% $1,766.95 $80.53 month 44 $19,658.86
6.5% $1,688.02 $159.46 month 22 $43,337.68
6.0% $1,610.75 $236.73 month 15 $66,514.97
5.5% $1,535.22 $312.26 month 11 $89,177.24
5.0% $1,461.48 $386.00 month 9 $111,301.08

A quarter-point cut takes over seven years to repay its costs. A one-and-a-half point cut takes a little over a year. The table shows how sharply the answer depends on the size of the cut, and it also depends on your costs and how long you will stay.

If the new rate is higher than your current one, refinancing never pays, and the calculator says so.

The term reset trap

This is where refinancing quietly costs people money. The new loan usually starts a fresh term, 30 years, say, even if you have only 25 left. That always lowers the payment. It does not always lower the cost.

Same loan, same 6.0%, but stretched to 30 years:

New 25-year loan New 30-year loan
Payment $1,610.75 $1,498.88
Saved each month $236.73 $348.60
Interest still to pay $233,227.39 $289,593.37
Saved over the life $66,514.97 $10,148.99

The 30-year loan has the bigger monthly saving and more than $56,000 less lifetime saving. It also adds 60 months of payments. Look at five years in: it shows $13,111.58 ahead, against $14,204.58 for the shorter term, close, but by the time the 25-year loan would have ended you are still paying.

If you refinance into a longer loan, you can protect yourself by paying the amount the shorter term would have required. The calculator shows what the payment and lifetime saving would be at your remaining term.

Closing costs can be paid in cash or added to the new loan. Rolling them in saves you cash on the day, but you then pay interest on them.

On the example, adding the $4,500 gives a $254,500 loan:

  • Payment $1,639.75 instead of $1,610.75
  • Monthly saving $207.73 instead of $236.73
  • Break-even month 16 instead of 15
  • Saving over the loan $62,319.34 instead of $66,514.97

That is about $4,200 more over the life of the loan. If you can afford the cash, paying up front is cheaper. If you cannot, rolling them in is reasonable. It just is not free. Be equally careful with “no-closing-cost” offers: they work by either raising your rate or adding the costs to the loan.

Before you refinance

  • Use real costs. Your lender’s Loan Estimate itemises the fees. Include them all.
  • Count what you will really keep the loan. If a move is likely in the next few years, the break-even matters most.
  • Do not reset the clock without noticing. If you want a lower payment, a longer term is a choice. If you want to save money, keep the term the same or shorter.
  • Check you will qualify. The rate you are quoted depends on your credit, your income and the value of the property.
  • Keep your other plans in mind. If you are planning extra payments, compare with the loan payoff calculator, which shows how much a lump sum or monthly overpayment saves on the loan you already have.

How it is calculated

The payment on a loan of B at monthly rate i over n months is:

B × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)⁻ⁿ)

The calculator builds the schedule for the loan you have and for the new one, rounding interest to the cent each month. At every month it takes the payments made so far plus the balance still owed, and subtracts any closing costs paid up front. The saving is the difference between the two loans. The break-even is the first month it turns positive.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if refinancing is worth it?

Compare what it costs with what it saves, and ask how long you will keep the loan. The break-even month is when the savings have repaid the closing costs. If you will keep the loan well past it, refinancing is likely to pay. If you might sell or move before it, it is not. On $250,000 at 7.5% refinanced to 6.0% with $4,500 of costs, you break even in month 15.

How is the break-even point calculated?

A common rule of thumb divides the closing costs by the monthly saving: $4,500 ÷ $236.73 = 19.01 months. This calculator goes further. Each month it compares what you would have paid plus what you would still owe with and without the refinance, and reports the first month you are ahead. It comes out earlier (month 15) because a lower rate also pays the balance down faster.

Is a longer new term a good idea?

It lowers the payment, but it can cost far more overall. Refinancing the same loan into a new 30-year term at 6.0% cuts the payment to $1,498.88 but saves $10,148.99 over the whole loan, against $66,514.97 if the term stays at 25 years. The calculator shows the comparison whenever the new term is longer than what you have left.

Should I roll the closing costs into the loan?

It saves cash on closing day but you pay interest on the costs. On the example, rolling in $4,500 means a $254,500 loan, a payment of $1,639.75 rather than $1,610.75, and a break-even in month 16 instead of 15. The lifetime saving falls by about $4,200. It is reasonable if you lack the cash, but costs more.

What if the new rate is only slightly lower?

The break-even stretches out quickly. Dropping from 7.5% to 7.0% on the same loan saves $80.53 a month and takes 44 months to pay back $4,500 of costs. Dropping to 7.25% saves only $40.46 a month and takes 87 months, over seven years, to break even. A small rate cut with high costs is rarely worth it unless you will keep the loan a long time.

What closing costs should I include?

Everything the lender charges to close the new loan: origination or application fees, appraisal, title search and insurance, recording and similar charges. Your Loan Estimate lists them. Do not include costs that you would pay anyway, and be wary of "no-closing-cost" offers, which usually raise the rate or add the costs to the loan instead.

Which refinance calculator should I use, this one or the mortgage one?

Use this one when you know your current balance, your rate and the months left, on a mortgage or any other loan. Use the mortgage refinance calculator when you only remember the original loan and how long you have paid, or when the offer involves points or cash out; it works out the balance for you.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.