Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Debt Consolidation Calculator

A consolidation loan almost always lowers the monthly payment. Whether it saves money is a different question. This compares the totals.

Last reviewed

What you owe now
$
%
$
$
%
$
$
%
$
$
%
$

Leave a balance at zero to skip that row.

The consolidation loan
%
months
%

Consolidating saves

$3,721

$742 a month against $870 now

Total owed
$28,700
Average rate now
17.08%
Paying now
$870
New payment
$742
Your debts as they stand
DebtBalanceRateMonthsInterest
Debt 1$8,00022.9%49.9$4,475
Debt 2$5,50018.5%41.6$1,993
Debt 3$12,0009.9%45.1$2,417
Debt 4$3,20026.99%41.2$1,740
Side by side
As you areConsolidated
Monthly payment$870$742
Months to clear49.948
Interest paid$10,626$6,905
Total paid$39,326$35,605

Keep paying the $870 you pay now rather than dropping to $742, and the loan clears far sooner than 48 months, which is where the real saving in a consolidation usually lives.

A lower payment is not a saving

Almost any consolidation loan will cut your monthly payment. That is easy. It only requires a longer term. Whether it saves you money is a completely separate question, and it is the one this page answers.

Four debts, paid at their current rates and payments until they clear:

Debt Balance Rate Months to clear Interest
Card A $8,000 22.90% 49.9 $4,475
Card B $5,500 18.50% 41.6 $1,993
Car loan $12,000 9.90% 45.1 $2,417
Store card $3,200 26.99% 41.2 $1,740
Total $28,700 17.08% 49.9 $10,626

Paying $870 a month, these cost $39,326 and are gone in just under four years.

What the term does

Consolidate that $28,700 at 11%:

Term Monthly payment Total paid Saving
24 months $1,337.64 $32,103 $7,223
36 months $939.60 $33,826 $5,500
48 months $741.77 $35,605 $3,721
60 months $624.01 $37,440 $1,886
72 months $546.28 $39,332 −$6
96 months $450.83 $43,280 −$3,954
120 months $395.34 $47,441 −$8,115

Every row cuts the monthly payment. Only the top four save money.

At 72 months the deal is exactly break-even: $6 worse than doing nothing, despite cutting the payment from $870 to $546. Past that point you are paying substantially more for the privilege of paying less each month.

This is the trap, and it is not a subtle one. Lenders advertise the monthly figure because it is the number that sells.

The rate you need to beat

Not the rate on your worst card. The balance-weighted average of what you pay now:

Simple average of the four rates 19.57%
Balance-weighted average 17.08%

The weighted figure is lower because the biggest balance, the $12,000 car loan , carries the lowest rate. Averaging the rates without weighting them overstates what you are paying and makes consolidation look better than it is.

At 48 months:

New rate Monthly Total Saving
7% $687.26 $32,988 $6,338
9% $714.20 $34,282 $5,044
11% $741.77 $35,605 $3,721
14% $784.27 $37,645 $1,681
17.08% $829.33 $39,808 −$482
20% $873.35 $41,921 −$2,595

Consolidating at the weighted average rate loses money, because you have restarted the clock on debts that were already partly paid.

The trick that makes it work

Here is where most of the benefit actually comes from, and it costs nothing:

Keep paying what you pay now.

Consolidate at 11% over 48 months and the required payment drops to $741.77. Carry on paying the $870 you were already managing, and:

  • The loan clears in 39.5 months instead of 48
  • Total paid is $34,333 instead of $35,605
  • You save a further $1,272

The lower payment is an option, not an instruction. Treating it as breathing room is reasonable; treating it as a reason to spend the difference is how consolidation stops helping.

The alternative that costs nothing

Before taking a loan, compare it against simply redirecting the same $870. As each debt clears, its payment rolls onto the next one, the avalanche method if you target the highest rate first, the snowball method if you target the smallest balance.

Approach Months Total paid
Change nothing 49.9 $39,326
Avalanche, highest rate first 46 $39,235
Consolidate at 11% over 48 months 48 $35,605
Consolidate, keep paying $870 39.5 $34,333

Two honest observations about this table.

Avalanche barely helps here, $91, because the existing payments were already clearing these debts within a few months of each other, so there is little to reallocate. On a set of debts with very different payoff dates it does far more.

The avalanche and snowball results are identical in this example, at 46 months and $39,235, purely because the smallest balance also carries the highest rate. They normally differ, and avalanche is always the cheaper of the two when they do.

What beats both is the bottom row: the better rate and the discipline of keeping the old payment. The rate does the work; the payment decides how much of that work you keep.

When a debt never clears

If the payment does not cover the monthly interest, the balance grows and the debt is permanent. A $10,000 balance at 24% accrues $200 a month, pay $150 and you go backwards forever.

The calculator reports “never” for those rather than a very large number, because that is the truth and because it changes the decision entirely. If any of your debts are in that state, the question is not whether consolidation saves money but how quickly you can stop the bleeding.

Before you rely on the number

  • Include the fees. Origination charges and balance transfer fees of 3–5% can wipe out a modest saving. There is a field for them above.
  • Check for prepayment penalties on the existing debts, which some loans carry.
  • Watch the promotional rates. A 0% balance transfer that reverts to 24% after 18 months is a different product from a fixed-rate loan.
  • The cards will be empty afterwards. Consolidation clears balances without clearing habits, and running them up again leaves you owing the old debt and the new loan at once. That is the most common way this goes wrong, and no calculator can warn you about it except in words.

Frequently asked questions

Does debt consolidation actually save money?

Only if the total falls, and that depends on the term as much as the rate. Consolidating $28,700 at 11% over 48 months saves about $3,721 against leaving four debts alone. The same loan over 60 months has a lower payment and saves only $1,886.

Why does a lower monthly payment not mean saving?

Because a payment can be lowered simply by stretching the term. Over 120 months the same consolidation costs more in total than doing nothing, while looking far cheaper each month. The calculator flags that case explicitly.

What rate do I need for consolidation to be worth it?

Lower than the balance-weighted average of what you pay now, which is usually below the rate on your worst card. On the example above the weighted average is 17.08%, not the 19.57% you get by averaging the four rates, because the biggest balance carries the lowest rate.

Should I keep paying the old amount?

If you can, yes. It is where most of the benefit is. Consolidating lowers the required payment; continuing to pay what you paid before clears the loan far sooner and cuts the interest substantially.

What if my payment does not cover the interest?

Then the balance grows and the debt never clears. A $10,000 balance at 24% accrues $200 a month, so paying $150 goes backwards forever. The calculator reports "never" rather than a very large number, and that situation is the strongest case for changing something.

What are the risks?

Two. Fees and balance transfer charges can erase a modest saving, so include them. And consolidation clears your cards without clearing the habit, running the balances back up leaves you with the old debt and the new loan together.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.