Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Mortgage Refinance Calculator: Points, Cash-Out and Break-Even

Enter your original loan, how long you have paid and the new offer. You will see your balance, the break-even month, how much better or worse off you are over the time you will stay, and the highest rate that pays. If you already know your balance and months left, the refinance calculator starts from those.

Last reviewed

Your current mortgage
$
%
years
years
months
The new offer
%
years
$
$
years

If you keep it 7 years

+$11,721

better off with the refinance, counting what you owe at the end

Current payment
$1,995.91
New payment
$1,693.10
Monthly change
−$302.81
Break-even
2 years
Costs
$5,324 ($2,824 points)
Highest rate that still pays
6.591%

Your balance now is $282,395 with 25 years left.

The new loan runs 5 years longer than what you have left, which lowers the payment but adds interest: $327,120 on the new loan against $316,375 still to pay now. At the new rate over the 25 years you have left, the payment would be $1,819.47 and the interest $263,448.

How much better or worse off, by how long you keep the loan
Keep itRefinance is
1 year$2,543 behind
2 years$141 ahead
3 years$2,716 ahead
5 years$7,501 ahead
7 years$11,721 ahead
10 years$16,745 ahead

It adds what you would have paid out to what you would still owe, with and without the refinance. Principal and interest only; taxes, insurance and any change in mortgage insurance are not included. 300 months remain on your current loan.

Start from the loan you have

Most people remember the mortgage they took out: the amount, the rate, the term. They rarely know today’s balance. So this calculator starts there. Enter the original loan and how long you have been paying, and it works out the balance and the months left. Then it tests the new offer against carrying on.

The example throughout: a $300,000 30-year loan at 7%, with 5 years paid. The payment is $1,995.91, the balance is $282,394.53, and there are 300 months left.

The offer, and what it costs

The new offer is 6% over 30 years, with one point and $2,500 of other costs.

  • Points. An upfront charge that buys a lower rate. The CFPB explains that each point is 1% of the loan, so one point on a $100,000 loan is $1,000, and partial points are allowed. Here, one point on $282,394.53 is $2,823.95.
  • Other closing costs. $2,500 for fees, appraisal and so on.
  • Total cost: $5,323.95, paid at closing.

The new payment is $1,693.10, which is $302.81 less every month.

When does it pay for itself?

A common rule of thumb, which the CFPB gives for points, is to divide the cost by the monthly saving: $5,323.95 ÷ $302.81 = about 17.6 months.

That is a fair first guess, but it flatters the refinance, because part of the lower payment comes from paying down less of the loan. A more honest test adds what you would have paid out to what you would still owe, both ways, month by month. On that test the break-even is month 24.

If you keep the loan The refinance leaves you
1 year $2,542.51 behind
2 years $140.50 ahead
3 years $2,715.70 ahead
5 years $7,500.98 ahead
7 years $11,720.68 ahead
10 years $16,745.30 ahead

If you will move in 18 months, this offer loses money. If you will stay 7 years, it is worth nearly $12,000. The question to ask yourself is not “is the rate lower” but “will I still have this loan in 2 years?”

Rolling the costs in

You can add the costs to the loan instead of paying cash. The loan becomes $287,718.48, the payment $1,725.02, and nothing is due at closing. But you now pay interest on the costs. Break-even moves to month 27, and after 7 years you are $9,591.06 ahead instead of $11,720.68. Rolling in is convenient. It is not free.

The highest rate that still pays

The page also works backwards. Given your costs and how long you will stay, what is the highest new rate that still leaves you ahead? With the example costs it is 6.591% for a 7-year stay. Any offer at or below that beats keeping your loan; above it, you are behind.

For a 5-year stay it is 6.529%, and for 10 years, 6.593%. Use it to judge the offers you are quoted, without rerunning the sums for each.

The term reset

Refinancing into a 30-year loan with 25 years left adds five years. That lowers the payment, and can raise the cost of the loan even at a lower rate:

  • Interest still to pay on your current loan: $316,374.92
  • Interest on the new 30-year loan: $327,119.65, more by $10,744.73
  • If the new 6% loan ran only the 25 years you have left: payment $1,819.47 and interest $263,447.92

The same lower rate with the same term would save $52,927 of interest. Stretching the term gives most of it back. If you want the lower rate without extending the loan, ask for a 25-year or 20-year term.

A shorter term

At 5.5% over 15 years, the payment rises to $2,307.40, $311.49 more than now. But interest on the new loan is $132,937.19, against $316,374.92 left on the old one. It breaks even in month 15 and is $34,378.63 ahead after 7 years. A higher payment buys a far cheaper loan.

Taking cash out

A cash-out refinance borrows more than the balance. Take $20,000 out, with half a point and $3,000 of costs rolled in, and the new loan is $306,906.50. The payment is $1,840.06, against $1,720.15 without the cash, which is $119.91 more a month for borrowing $20,000.

The calculator keeps cash out apart from the savings, since borrowed money is not a saving. It shows what the cash adds to your payment. Remember the cash is borrowed against your home and repaid with interest, and that it extends how long you owe.

A lower rate is not enough

At 7.5%, higher than the 7% you have, the new payment is still $21.37 lower, only because the loan restarts at 30 years. It never breaks even. A lower payment can come from a longer term alone, and tells you nothing about whether the deal is good.

Before you refinance

  • Get the Loan Estimate from each lender and compare the same number of points. The CFPB suggests asking for one quote with points and one without.
  • Ask about mortgage insurance. A new loan can change it.
  • Think about how long you will stay. It is the biggest number in the sum.
  • Do not forget the old loan’s prepayment penalty, if it has one.

For a simpler break-even on any loan, see the refinance calculator. To see how extra payments compare, use the mortgage payoff calculator, and the amortization calculator shows what the term restart does to the split.

What this does not include

  • Taxes and insurance. Principal and interest only.
  • Tax deductions for points and interest.
  • Appraisal-based limits on how much you can borrow.
  • Adjustable rates. One fixed rate is used for each loan.

How it is calculated

Balance and months left come from the original loan’s schedule. Points are a percentage of the balance plus any cash out. The new payment is B × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)⁻ⁿ). At each month, the advantage is what you would pay on the current loan plus its balance, less the same for the new loan, less costs paid at closing. The break-even rate is found by trying rates to 0.001%. Interest is the balance times the rate over 1200, rounded to the cent each month. Amounts are exact decimals.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if refinancing my mortgage is worth it?

Compare what you would pay out plus what you would still owe, with and without the refinance, at the time you expect to move. On a $300,000 loan at 7% with 5 years paid, refinancing to 6% with $5,323.95 of costs is $140.50 ahead after 24 months, and $11,720.68 ahead after 7 years.

What is the break-even point on a refinance?

The month you have saved more than the refinance cost. The CFPB's rule of thumb divides the cost by the monthly saving: $5,323.95 ÷ $302.81 is about 17.6 months. Counting the balance as well gives 24 months, because the new payment is lower partly by paying down less principal.

What are mortgage points?

An upfront charge that lowers your rate. Each point is 1% of the loan; one point on $100,000 is $1,000, and partial points such as 0.5 are allowed. The CFPB says points can make sense if you will keep the loan a long time. Enter the points the lender quotes and the rate they give you.

What is the highest rate at which a refinance still pays?

The calculator searches for it. With the example costs and a 7-year stay, any new rate up to 6.591% leaves you ahead, and above that you are behind. Compare it with offers you are quoted. A longer stay raises the rate that works, up to a point.

What does a cash-out refinance cost?

It adds to the loan and the payment. Taking $20,000 out on the example, rolled into the loan, raises the new payment from $1,720.15 to $1,840.06, $119.91 a month more. The cash is borrowed money, so the savings figures leave it out.

Can a lower rate still cost me more?

Yes, if the term restarts. Refinancing 25 years left into a new 30-year loan at 6% lowers the payment, but the interest on the new loan is $327,119.65 against $316,374.92 left on the old one. At the same 6% over the 25 years you have left, the interest would be $263,447.92.

Should I use this or the general refinance calculator?

Use this one when you remember the original mortgage and how long you have paid, and want points, closing costs or cash out in the comparison; it works out your balance for you. If you already know the balance you owe and the months left, the refinance calculator starts from those and works on any loan.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.