Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Rental Property Calculator

Enter the price, the rent and the real running costs. You will get the three figures that matter, and see why a good cap rate can still produce almost no cash.

Last reviewed

$
$
$
$
$
%
Annual running costs
$
$
$
$
%
%
years

Monthly cash flow

$50.67

6.59% cap rate · 0.88% cash-on-cash

Cap rate
6.59%
Cash-on-cash
0.88%
DSCR
1.03
1% rule
0.87%
Where the rent goes, each year
Gross rent$31,200
Vacancy at 5%−$1,560
Property tax−$3,600
Insurance−$1,500
Maintenance and repairs−$2,400
Management−$2,371
Net operating income$19,769
Mortgage−$19,161
Cash flow$608

The 6.59% cap rate describes the property and ignores your mortgage. The 0.88% cash-on-cash is the return on the $69,000 you actually put in. When the second is far below the first, debt service is taking the difference.

Operating expenses are 33.3% of collected rent. Appreciation, tax relief and principal paydown are not counted here. This is cash in and cash out.

Three numbers, measuring three different things

Most rental calculators give you one return figure. That is the problem, because the three standard measures answer different questions and disagree constantly.

  • Cap rate = NOI ÷ price. Describes the property. Ignores your mortgage entirely, which is what makes it comparable between buyers.
  • Cash-on-cash = annual cash flow ÷ cash invested. Describes your deal. Depends completely on how you financed it.
  • DSCR = NOI ÷ debt service. What the lender checks. Below about 1.20 and financing gets difficult.

Here is the reference deal: a $300,000 property, $60,000 down, $9,000 closing, renting at $2,600 a month, with a $240,000 mortgage at 7%.

Gross rent · $2,600 × 12 $31,200
Less 5% vacancy −$1,560
Effective income $29,640
Property tax −$3,600
Insurance −$1,500
Maintenance −$2,400
Management at 8% −$2,371
Net operating income $19,769
Mortgage · $1,596.73 × 12 −$19,161
Annual cash flow $608

So: a 6.59% cap rate and a 0.88% cash-on-cash return on the same property, on the same day.

That is not a contradiction. The property genuinely earns 6.59% on its price. The mortgage takes 97% of that net income, leaving $50.67 a month for the person who put in $69,000.

When cash-on-cash sits far below cap rate, debt service is the reason.

Your deposit changes everything except the cap rate

Down payment Cap rate Annual cash flow Cash-on-cash DSCR
$60,000 6.59% $608 0.88% 1.03
$90,000 6.59% $3,003 3.03% 1.18
$120,000 6.59% $5,398 4.18% 1.38
$150,000 6.59% $7,793 4.90% 1.65
$300,000 (cash) 6.59% $19,769 6.40% n/a

The cap rate never moves, because it is a fact about the building. Everything else does.

Note the DSCR column. At $60,000 down it is 1.03, the rent covers the mortgage by three per cent. One vacant month, one boiler, and the shortfall is yours. Most lenders would want 1.20 here, which this deal only reaches at about $90,000 down.

The two expenses people leave out

Vacancy and management. Leave both out and the same deal looks like this:

Honest Optimistic
Cap rate 6.59% 7.90%
Annual cash flow $608 $4,539

The cap rate is overstated by 1.31 percentage points and the cash flow is seven times too high, on identical property, rent and mortgage. Nothing was falsified; two real costs were simply assumed away.

  • Vacancy is not optional. Tenants leave, properties sit empty between lets, and 5% is about two and a half weeks a year, often optimistic.
  • Management at 8–10% applies even if you self-manage, because your time has value and because you may not always want the job.

Capital expenditure is the third common omission: roofs, boilers, windows and appliances do not appear in any given year and are certain across ten.

How much rent does the deal actually need?

At $60,000 down on this property:

Monthly rent Annual cash flow Per month Cap rate
$2,200 −$3,587 −$298.93 5.19%
$2,400 −$1,490 −$124.13 5.89%
$2,600 $608 $50.67 6.59%
$2,800 $2,706 $225.47 7.29%
$3,000 $4,803 $400.27 7.99%

Two hundred dollars of monthly rent is roughly $2,100 a year of cash flow, because it lands almost entirely on the bottom line once the fixed costs are covered. Rent assumptions deserve more scrutiny than almost any other input.

The 50% rule, and what our own example omits

A long-standing rule of thumb says that over time, operating expenses plus vacancy consume about half of gross rent, including the repairs and replacements that do not show up in any particular year.

Our example totals $11,431 of vacancy and expenses against $31,200 of gross rent. That is 36.6%, comfortably under the rule. The $4,169 gap is roughly what the rule reserves for capital expenditure that our line items never mention: the roof, the boiler, the windows, the kitchen.

Run the same deal on the 50% assumption and it looks very different:

Our line items 50% rule
NOI $19,769 $15,600
Cap rate 6.59% 5.20%
Annual cash flow $608 −$3,561
Per month $50.67 −$296.75

A deal that cash flows slightly becomes one that costs $297 a month.

Neither figure is the truth. The 50% rule is a crude average across property types and ages, and a new-build with a warranty will beat it while a hundred-year-old house will not. But if your analysis comes in far below 50%, that gap is your capital expenditure assumption, and it is worth naming rather than discovering.

The 1% rule, and what it is for

Monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. Our $2,600 on $300,000 is 0.87%, so this deal fails the screen, and indeed it barely cash flows.

The rule is a filter, not a verdict. It ignores property taxes entirely, which vary enough between states to decide a deal on their own. Use it to pick which properties to analyse properly; never use it to buy one.

The gross rent multiplier (price ÷ annual rent) does the same job from the other direction. Ours is 9.62. Lower is better, and like the 1% rule it is blind to costs.

Before you rely on the number

  • This is cash, not total return. Appreciation, depreciation deductions and the mortgage principal you pay down each month are all real and none are counted here. A deal that only works once you include them is a deal betting on assumptions.
  • Verify the rent, ideally against what comparable units actually let for rather than what the seller claims.
  • Property tax often resets on sale. Budgeting from the seller’s current bill can understate it substantially.
  • Thin cash flow is fragile. At a DSCR near 1.0 you are the reserve fund. Hold several months of expenses in cash before buying, not after.

Frequently asked questions

How do I calculate cap rate?

Net operating income divided by the purchase price. NOI is rent after vacancy and all operating expenses, but before the mortgage. A property producing $19,769 of NOI on a $300,000 purchase has a cap rate of 6.59%.

What is the difference between cap rate and cash-on-cash return?

Cap rate ignores financing entirely. It describes the property. Cash-on-cash is your annual cash flow divided by the cash you actually invested, so it depends on your mortgage. The same property can show a 6.59% cap rate and a 0.88% cash-on-cash return, because debt service takes nearly all the net income.

What is the 1% rule?

A screening shortcut: monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. A $300,000 property would need $3,000 a month. It is a filter for deciding what to analyse properly, not a measure of whether a deal works. It ignores taxes, insurance and everything else.

What expenses do people forget?

Vacancy and management, overwhelmingly. Assuming a property is let every week of the year and that your time is free overstates net income by more than 10% before anything else goes wrong. Capital expenditure, roofs, boilers, appliances, is the other common omission.

What is DSCR and why does it matter?

Debt service coverage ratio: net operating income divided by annual mortgage payments. Lenders on investment property typically want 1.20 or better, meaning the rent covers the mortgage with 20% to spare. A DSCR near 1.0 means any bad month comes out of your pocket.

Does this include appreciation and tax benefits?

No. This is cash in and cash out. Appreciation, depreciation deductions and the principal you pay down each month are all real returns, but they are not cash, and a deal that only works once you count them is a deal that depends on assumptions.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.