Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler Savings: Which Heats Your Home for Less?

Enter the heat your home needs, your gas and electricity prices, the boiler’s efficiency, the heat pump’s SCOP and the install costs. You will see each running cost, the saving, the break-even SCOP and the payback.

Last reviewed

kWh a year
$
%
$
$
$

The figures shown are examples. Use your own energy prices, your installer’s SCOP and real quotes.

The heat pump costs less to run by

$267 a year

the extra install cost is repaid in 20.6 years

Boiler running cost a year
$1,067
Heat pump running cost a year
$800
Boiler, cost of 1 kWh of heat
$0.0889
Heat pump, cost of 1 kWh of heat
$0.0667
Break-even SCOP
2.25
Break-even electricity price
$0.2667 per kWh
Net over 15 years
−$1,500
Energy used a year
13,333 kWh gas or 4,000 kWh power

Nothing is discounted. Maintenance, grants, a smart tariff and the cost of upgrading radiators are not included unless you put them in the installation costs. A heat pump’s real SCOP depends on the home and the installation, so ask for a figure for yours.

Comparing the cost of heat, not the cost of fuel

A gas boiler turns gas into heat. A heat pump moves heat from outside into your home using electricity. Because the heat pump delivers more heat than the electricity it uses, the two are best compared by the cost of one kilowatt-hour of heat delivered to the home, not by the price of a kilowatt-hour of gas or of electricity.

  • A boiler’s efficiency is the share of the gas’s energy that becomes heat. At 90% efficiency each kWh of heat needs 1 ÷ 0.9 = 1.11 kWh of gas.
  • A heat pump’s efficiency is its coefficient of performance, or COP: the useful heat delivered divided by the work put in. Over a year the average is the seasonal COP, SCOP, which gives a more realistic picture than a single test figure. A SCOP of 3 means 3 kWh of heat for each kWh of electricity.

This calculator holds no prices. Energy prices, grants and efficiencies differ widely and change, so you enter your own.

The calculation

  • Boiler, cost of 1 kWh of heat = gas price ÷ boiler efficiency.
  • Heat pump, cost of 1 kWh of heat = electricity price ÷ SCOP.
  • Running cost a year = heat needed a year × cost of a kWh of heat.
  • Break-even SCOP = electricity price × boiler efficiency ÷ gas price. Above it the heat pump is cheaper to run.
  • Payback = extra installation cost of the heat pump ÷ yearly saving in running cost.

Worked example

A home needs 12,000 kWh of heat a year. These are example figures: gas costs 0.08 a kWh and the boiler is 90% efficient; electricity costs 0.20 a kWh and the heat pump has a SCOP of 3. The heat pump costs 8,000 installed and a new boiler 2,500.

  • Boiler: 0.08 ÷ 0.9 = 0.0889 per kWh of heat, so 1,066.67 a year. It uses 13,333 kWh of gas.
  • Heat pump: 0.20 ÷ 3 = 0.0667 per kWh of heat, so 800.00 a year. It uses 4,000 kWh of electricity.
  • The heat pump saves 266.67 a year in running cost.
  • It costs 5,500 more to install, so the payback is 5,500 ÷ 266.67 = 20.63 years. Over 15 years the net result is −1,500.00, so on these figures it does not pay back in 15 years.
  • The break-even SCOP is 0.20 × 0.9 ÷ 0.08 = 2.25, and the break-even electricity price at a SCOP of 3 is 0.08 × 3 ÷ 0.9 = 0.2667 a kWh.

How the SCOP changes the answer

Same home and prices as above.

SCOP Heat pump a year Saving against the boiler
2.0 1,200.00 -133.33
2.5 960.00 106.67
3.0 800.00 266.67
3.5 685.71 380.95
4.0 600.00 466.67

Points to check

  • The ratio of the two prices matters most. The heat pump gains when electricity is cheap compared with gas. Some tariffs make electricity cheaper at certain times.
  • SCOP is not the same as the best COP. Wikipedia’s article on the coefficient of performance notes that seasonal figures for installed units are lower than test figures and give a more realistic picture. Ask your installer for a SCOP for your home.
  • Boilers get less efficient. Use the efficiency of the boiler you have or will buy, not a catalogue maximum.
  • Include the real install costs. Grants lower the heat pump price. Radiators, pipework and a hot water cylinder may add to it.
  • Think beyond cost. Comfort, noise, space and your plans for the home matter too.

Related tools: the electricity cost calculator, the solar panel payback calculator, the payback period calculator and the BTU calculator.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare a heat pump with a gas boiler?

Work out the cost of one kWh of heat for each. For a boiler divide the gas price by its efficiency. For a heat pump divide the electricity price by its seasonal COP. Multiply by the heat your home needs in a year. The calculator does this and shows the saving.

What is SCOP?

The seasonal coefficient of performance is the average COP over a whole heating season: heat delivered divided by electricity used. A SCOP of 3 means 3 kWh of heat for each kWh of electricity. It is a more realistic figure than a single test COP.

What is the break-even SCOP?

It is the SCOP at which the heat pump and the boiler cost the same to run: electricity price times boiler efficiency, divided by gas price. A heat pump with a SCOP above it is cheaper to run. The calculator shows it for your prices.

Why can a heat pump cost more to run?

When electricity is expensive compared with gas, the heat pump’s extra efficiency may not make up the price difference. The break-even SCOP shows how efficient it must be. Cheaper electricity tariffs or a higher SCOP change the result.

Are installation costs and grants included?

Only through the installation costs you enter. Put in the heat pump price after any grant, and the boiler price. The payback is the extra installation cost divided by the yearly running saving. Maintenance and radiator upgrades are not separate items.

Is the result a recommendation?

No. It compares running costs from the numbers you enter and does not discount future money. Real heat demand, a heat pump’s SCOP in your home, future prices and comfort all matter. Get quotes and a survey before deciding.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.