Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

Mutual Fund Calculator

Enter your investment and the fund’s fees. The expense ratio compounds against you exactly as returns compound for you, and the total is rarely what people expect.

Last reviewed

$
$
%
The fees
%
%
%

Value after fees

$40,387

$49,268 without any fees · 7% net return

You paid in
$10,000
Growth
$30,387
Fees cost you
$8,881
Of what you would have had
18%

Fees took $8,881, 18% of the $49,268 you would otherwise have had

A 1% expense ratio does not cost 1% of your money. It is charged every year on a growing balance, so it compounds against you exactly as returns compound for you.

Where the fees went
Expense ratio, charged yearly$4,341
Total cost, including lost growth$8,881
Year by year
YearGrowthFeesBalance
1$723$103$10,723
2$775$111$11,498
3$831$119$12,329
4$891$127$13,221
5$956$137$14,176
6$1,025$146$15,201
7$1,099$157$16,300
8$1,178$168$17,478
9$1,264$181$18,742
10$1,355$194$20,097
11$1,453$208$21,549
12$1,558$223$23,107
13$1,670$239$24,778
14$1,791$256$26,569
15$1,921$274$28,489
16$2,060$294$30,549
17$2,208$315$32,757
18$2,368$338$35,125
19$2,539$363$37,665
20$2,723$389$40,387

A steady return every year, which no fund delivers. The fee figures are the reliable part of this calculation; the return is the assumption.

A 1% fee does not cost 1%

This is the whole point of the page, so here it is first.

$10,000 invested at an 8% annual return for 20 years:

With no fees $49,268
With a 1% expense ratio $40,387
The fee cost you $8,881

That is 18% of everything you would otherwise have had, taken by a fee advertised as one per cent.

The reason is that the fee is charged every year, on a growing balance. It compounds against you in exactly the way returns compound for you. One per cent of $10,000 is $100; one per cent of $45,000 is $450; and every dollar taken also stops earning for all the years that follow.

It gets worse with time

Same $10,000, same 8%, same 1% expense ratio:

Term Without fees With 1% Cost Share lost
5 years $14,898 $14,176 $722 4.8%
10 years $22,196 $20,097 $2,100 9.5%
20 years $49,268 $40,387 $8,881 18.0%
30 years $109,357 $81,165 $28,192 25.8%
40 years $242,734 $163,114 $79,620 32.8%

Over a full working life, a one per cent fee takes about a third of what you would have accumulated.

This is the strongest argument for low-cost funds, and it has nothing to do with performance. The fee is certain. The outperformance is not. A fund charging 1% more must beat a cheaper one by 1% every single year just to draw level, and keep doing it.

Expense ratios compared

Expense ratio $10,000 after 20 years Cost against no fee
0.10% $48,299 $969
0.50% $44,608 $4,660
1.00% $40,387 $8,881
1.50% $36,564 $12,704

The gap between a 0.10% index fund and a 1.50% actively managed one is $11,735 on a $10,000 investment, more than the original investment itself.

Sales loads cost more than they look

A front load comes off before anything is invested. Pay 5% on $10,000 and only $9,500 goes to work.

Over 20 years at 8%, that $9,500 grows to $46,805 instead of $49,268. The load cost you $2,463, nearly five times the $500 you handed over, because you also lost every year of growth the $500 would have produced.

A back load is simpler: a percentage of the balance when you sell. It is charged once, on the largest the balance will ever be.

Both are worth questioning. Index funds generally charge neither.

The same thing happens to regular saving

Most people do not invest a lump sum once; they put money in every month. The fee drag works identically.

$200 a month for 30 years at 8%: $72,000 paid in:

Expense ratio Ends with Fee cost Share lost
0.10% $292,090 $5,982 2.0%
0.50% $269,489 $28,583 9.6%
1.00% $243,994 $54,078 18.1%
1.50% $221,236 $76,836 25.8%

Note the bottom row: the fee cost of $76,836 is more than the $72,000 you contributed over thirty years. You would have paid the fund more than you paid yourself.

The share lost is almost identical to the lump-sum table: 18.1% against 18.0% for a 1% fee. The percentage the fee takes depends on the rate and the term, not on how the money arrives.

What the fee is for

An expense ratio pays for management, administration, custody and marketing. A fund that genuinely does something hard, researching individual companies, operating in difficult markets, costs more to run than one that tracks an index automatically.

So the question is not whether a fee is high but whether it buys anything. Two tests:

  • Compare against the right benchmark. A fund charging 1% to track something close to an index is expensive for what it does.
  • Look at net returns, not gross. The return published is usually already after the expense ratio, but not after sales loads.

Fees are the one certain input

Everything else in this calculation is a guess. Nobody knows what returns the next twenty years will bring, and a page claiming to project them precisely is not being straight with you.

The fees, by contrast, are contractual. They will be charged whatever happens. That asymmetry is why it makes sense to spend effort minimising costs rather than selecting funds on past returns, one is within your control and the other is not.

Set the return in this calculator to something conservative and then vary the expense ratio. The fee column barely moves; the outcome does.

Before you rely on the number

  • The return is an assumption, and a steady one at that. Real funds have good years and bad, and the order matters if you are withdrawing.
  • Tax is not modelled. Funds held outside a tax-sheltered account generate taxable distributions, and high-turnover funds generate more of them.
  • The published expense ratio may not be everything. Trading costs inside the fund are real and are not included in it.
  • Check the share class. The same fund often comes in several, with different loads and expense ratios for different investors.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a 1% expense ratio really cost?

Far more than 1%. On $10,000 growing at 8% for 20 years, a 1% expense ratio leaves $40,387 instead of $49,268. It costs $8,881, or 18% of what you would otherwise have had. The fee is charged every year on a growing balance, so it compounds against you.

What is an expense ratio?

The fund’s annual running cost, charged as a percentage of your balance and deducted before the return you see. You never get an invoice for it, which is part of why it goes unnoticed.

What is a sales load?

A commission on buying or selling the fund. A front load comes off before any money is invested, a 5% load on $10,000 invests only $9,500, and you lose both the $500 and every year of growth it would have earned. A back load is charged when you sell.

How much does the expense ratio matter over time?

It grows with the term. The same 1% fee costs about 5% of your balance over 5 years, 10% over 10 and 18% over 20. Over a working lifetime it can take a quarter or more of what you would have accumulated.

Is a low expense ratio always better?

The fee is certain and the outperformance is not, which is the argument for low-cost index funds. A fund charging 1% more has to beat a cheaper one by 1% every year just to break even with it, and must keep doing so.

Does this calculator predict my returns?

No. It assumes a steady return every year, which no fund delivers. Treat the return as an assumption and the fee figures as the reliable part, the fees are contractual and the returns are not.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.