Skip to content
thecalculatorstudio

EV vs Petrol Total Cost of Ownership: Which Car Costs Less Over the Years?

Enter the prices, your driving, electricity and petrol prices, maintenance, insurance and resale values. You will see the total cost of each car, the saving, the cost per kilometre and the year the electric car catches up.

Last reviewed

km

Electric car

$
%
kWh/100 km
%
$
$
$

Petrol car

$
%
l/100 km
$
$
$

The numbers when the page opens are examples. Use real quotes and your own prices.

The EV costs less over 8 years by

$5,773

$722 a year; the EV catches up after 3.7 years

Cost of ownership
ElectricPetrol
Loss of value (price − resale)$20,000$15,000
Running cost a year$533$1,680
All yearly costs$1,733$3,080
Total over 8 years$33,867$39,640
Cost per km$0.282$0.330

Nothing is discounted, and resale values, fuel and power prices and repairs are guesses about the future. Test a cautious case, such as a lower EV resale value, before deciding.

Why the sticker price is only part of the answer

An electric car usually costs more to buy than a similar petrol car, and usually costs less to run. Which one is cheaper over the years you keep it depends on how much you drive, what electricity and petrol cost where you live, and what each car is worth when you sell it. The total cost of ownership puts all of this on one line.

This calculator uses your own figures for everything. Prices, tariffs and resale values differ by country and change over time, so it holds none of its own.

The calculation

For each car:

  • Loss of value = purchase price − resale value, where resale value is a share of the purchase price at the end of the period.
  • Running cost a year, electric = kilometres a year × kWh per 100 km ÷ 100 ÷ charging efficiency × electricity price. Dividing by charging efficiency counts the energy lost on the way into the battery. The US government’s fueleconomy.gov page on electric vehicles puts battery charging efficiency at 84% to 93%.
  • Running cost a year, petrol = kilometres a year × litres per 100 km ÷ 100 × petrol price.
  • Yearly costs = running cost + maintenance + insurance.
  • Total over the years = loss of value + years × yearly costs.

Because each total rises in a straight line with the years, the break-even point has a simple formula: the extra the electric car loses in value, divided by how much more the petrol car costs each year. Nothing is discounted for the time value of money.

Worked example

You drive 15,000 km a year and keep the car for 8 years. The electric car costs 40,000 and the petrol car 30,000. Both are worth half their price at the end. The electric car uses 16 kWh per 100 km, charging is 90% efficient and electricity averages 0.20 a kWh. The petrol car uses 7 litres per 100 km at 1.60 a litre. These are examples.

  • Electric running cost = 15,000 × 16 ÷ 100 ÷ 0.9 × 0.20 = 533.33 a year. With maintenance of 300 and insurance of 900 the yearly cost is 1,733.33.
  • Petrol running cost = 15,000 × 7 ÷ 100 × 1.60 = 1,680.00 a year. With maintenance of 600 and insurance of 800 the yearly cost is 3,080.00.
  • Loss of value: the electric car loses 20,000 and the petrol car 15,000.
  • Total over 8 years: electric 20,000 + 8 × 1,733.33 = 33,866.67, petrol 15,000 + 8 × 3,080 = 39,640.00.
  • The electric car costs 5,773.33 less, which is 721.67 a year, or 0.282 per km against 0.330 per km.
  • It starts 5,000 behind in lost value and gains 1,346.67 a year, so it catches up after 5,000 ÷ 1,346.67 = 3.71 years.

How the answer changes with the years kept

Same cars and figures. Positive means the electric car is cheaper.

Years kept Electric saves
2 -2,306.67
4 386.67
6 3,080.00
8 5,773.33
10 8,466.67

Points to check

  • Resale value is the biggest guess. Used electric car values depend on battery condition and technology that is changing quickly. Try a lower figure for the electric car.
  • Use your own driving. A low-mileage driver gets less from lower running costs and may never reach break-even.
  • Use your own electricity price. Home charging often costs less than public charging. The EV charging cost calculator works out a blended price from a home and public split.
  • Count the home charger. If you need to install one, add its cost to the electric car’s purchase price.
  • Other costs. Tolls, parking, tax, grants and financing are not included. Add them to the prices and yearly costs if they apply.

Related tools: the EV charging cost calculator, the miles per kWh calculator, the fuel cost calculator and the car loan calculator.

Frequently asked questions

What is total cost of ownership?

It is everything a car costs over the years you own it: the loss in value between buying and selling, plus fuel or electricity, maintenance and insurance. It is a fairer comparison than the purchase price alone, because the cheaper car to buy is often the dearer one to run.

When does an electric car become cheaper than a petrol car?

When the running cost saving has made up the extra it loses in value. Divide the extra loss in value by the yearly saving. With example figures this takes 3.7 years. If the electric car is also cheaper to own from the start, there is no break-even.

Why does resale value matter so much?

It sets how much of the purchase price you lose. A difference of ten points in resale value on a 40,000 car is 4,000, which can erase years of fuel savings. Resale values are uncertain, so test a cautious figure for the electric car.

How is the electricity cost worked out?

Kilometres driven times kWh per 100 km, divided by 100 and by the charging efficiency, times your average price per kWh. Dividing by efficiency counts the energy lost while charging. Use an average of your home and public prices.

Does the calculator include loan interest or grants?

No. It compares purchase price, resale, running costs, maintenance and insurance only. Add a grant by lowering the purchase price, and add finance costs to the yearly figures. Nothing is discounted for the time value of money.

Can I use miles instead of kilometres?

This page uses kilometres and litres per 100 km. To use miles, convert your yearly distance to kilometres and your fuel use to litres per 100 km. The cost per kilometre it shows can be multiplied by 1.609 for a cost per mile.

Related calculators

Sources

This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.