Contractor vs Employee: Which Offer Leaves You With More?
Enter the salary offer and the contract terms. You will see take-home for each, the difference a year, and the break-even hourly rate a contractor needs to match the job once benefits and expenses are counted.
Last reviewed
Contracting leaves you ahead by
$7,800 a year
$650 a month; break-even rate $43.94 an hour
- Employee take-home
- $45,000
- Employee total with benefits
- $51,000
- Contractor revenue
- $92,000
- Contractor profit
- $84,000
- Contractor take-home
- $58,800
- Billable hours a year
- 1,840
- Break-even hourly rate
- $43.94
- Your rate vs break-even
- +13.8%
- Salary that matches the contract
- $70,400
The employee side counts benefits at the value you put on them. A contractor gets none, but can spend take-home money on equivalent cover, so the contractor total is the take-home. Contract work also carries gaps between jobs, which the unpaid weeks capture only roughly.
Why a contract rate is not comparable with a salary
A contractor quoted 50 an hour looks as though they earn far more than someone on a salary of 60,000. The comparison is wrong in several ways. The salaried worker is paid for paid leave and public holidays, has an employer who pays part of their social contributions, and often receives health cover or pension contributions on top. The contractor pays their own business costs, covers every gap between jobs, and bears more of the tax.
This calculator turns both offers into the same thing: the money you keep in a year, with the employee’s benefits counted at the value you put on them. It also finds the break-even hourly rate, the lowest contract rate that matches the job offer.
How the law sees the difference
Whether you are an employee or a contractor is a question of fact, not of what the two sides prefer. The US Internal Revenue Service describes three kinds of evidence: behavioural (does the payer control what you do and how), financial (who controls the business side, such as how you are paid, expenses and tools) and the type of relationship (written contracts, benefits, how long it lasts). No single factor decides it. The IRS also states the tax difference: a business withholds tax from employees’ pay and pays the employer’s share of contributions, while generally it does not withhold or pay tax on payments to independent contractors, who handle their own. Other countries have their own tests, so check yours.
The calculation
- Employee take-home = salary × (1 − tax rate).
- Employee total = take-home + the yearly value of the benefits the employer provides.
- Contractor revenue = hourly rate × hours a week × (52 − unpaid weeks).
- Contractor profit = revenue − business expenses.
- Contractor take-home = profit × (1 − income tax rate − extra self-employment contributions rate).
- Break-even rate = (employee total ÷ (1 − income tax − extra contributions) + expenses) ÷ billed hours.
A contractor gets none of the benefits, but can spend take-home money on equivalent cover, so the contractor’s total is simply the take-home. Every tax rate is yours to enter, because it depends on the country, the income and how the business is registered.
Worked example
The job offer is a salary of 60,000 with tax of 25% and benefits you value at 6,000 a year. The contract pays 50 an hour for 40 billed hours a week, with 6 weeks a year unpaid. Business expenses are 8,000. Income tax on profit is 20% and extra self-employment contributions are 10%. These rates are examples.
- Employee take-home = 60,000 × 0.75 = 45,000. With benefits the total is 51,000.
- Billed hours = 46 weeks × 40 = 1,840. Revenue = 1,840 × 50 = 92,000. Profit = 92,000 − 8,000 = 84,000.
- Contractor take-home = 84,000 × (1 − 0.20 − 0.10) = 58,800.
- Difference = 58,800 − 51,000 = 7,800 a year in the contractor’s favour, which is 650 a month.
- Break-even profit = 51,000 ÷ 0.70 = 72,857.14, so the break-even rate = (72,857.14 + 8,000) ÷ 1,840 = 43.94 an hour. The 50 an hour entered is 13.8% above it.
- The employee salary that matches the contract is (58,800 − 6,000) ÷ 0.75 = 70,400.
Contractor take-home at different rates
Same figures as above, 1,840 billed hours and expenses of 8,000. The employee total is 51,000.
| Hourly rate | Profit | Take-home | Against the job |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | 65,600 | 45,920 | -5,080 |
| 45 | 74,800 | 52,360 | 1,360 |
| 50 | 84,000 | 58,800 | 7,800 |
| 55 | 93,200 | 65,240 | 14,240 |
| 60 | 102,400 | 71,680 | 20,680 |
Points to check
- Value the benefits honestly. Count only the benefits you would otherwise pay for, at what they would cost you.
- Count the gaps. If you expect weeks between contracts, raise the unpaid weeks. Billing 40 hours a week for 46 weeks is a steady-work assumption.
- Security. A salary continues when work is slow. A contract does not. Money cannot measure this, but you should weigh it.
- Check the rules where you live. Tax rates, contributions, and the test for who counts as an employee all differ between countries.
- Not advice. Ask an accountant before choosing, especially about tax.
Related tools: the freelance hourly rate calculator, the hourly to salary calculator, the salary to hourly calculator and the take-home paycheck calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare a contract rate with a salary?
Turn both into what you keep in a year. For the job, take the salary after tax and add the value of the benefits. For the contract, take the rate times billed hours, subtract expenses and then tax and contributions. The calculator does this and shows the difference.
What is the break-even hourly rate?
It is the lowest contract rate at which your take-home matches the total from the job offer, benefits included. The calculator finds it by dividing the job total by what you keep of each pound of profit, adding expenses, and spreading it over your billed hours.
Why do I enter extra contributions for the contractor?
A salaried worker’s employer pays part of the social contributions. A contractor often pays the whole amount. In the United States the IRS sets self-employment tax at 15.3% of net earnings. Enter the extra rate that applies in your country, or zero.
How should I value benefits?
Count what you would have to pay for yourself if the employer did not provide them, such as health cover and pension contributions, at what they would cost you. Leave out perks you would not buy. A higher value moves the break-even rate up.
Does the calculator consider whether I am legally a contractor?
No. That is a question of fact, not choice. The US IRS looks at behavioural control, financial control and the type of relationship, and no single factor decides it. Other countries use their own tests, so check the rules where you work.
What does it leave out?
It leaves out gaps between contracts beyond the unpaid weeks you enter, the security of a salary, late payments, insurance a contractor may need, and tax effects specific to your country. Treat the result as a starting point and ask an accountant.
Related calculators
- Freelance Hourly Rate CalculatorEnter the income you want to take home, your costs and your tax rate.
- Hourly to Salary CalculatorEnter your hourly rate and your normal week.
- Salary to Hourly CalculatorEnter your salary and your normal week.
- Take-Home Paycheck CalculatorEnter your pay, how often you are paid and what comes out.
- Pay Raise CalculatorEnter your pay and the rise, as a percentage, a cash figure, or just the new salary.
- Overtime CalculatorEnter your rate, your hours and the point overtime starts.
- Invoice Late Fee CalculatorEnter the invoice amount, the days it is overdue and the rate and fees you are allowed to charge.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service: Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee? (the three kinds of evidence and who withholds and pays tax)
- Internal Revenue Service: Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes), the 15.3% rate paid by the self-employed in the United States
This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.