Cash Back or Low Interest Rate?
Enter the price, the rebate, your bank's rate and the low rate. You will see which option costs less in total, and the rebate or rate at which the choice flips.
Last reviewed
Take the low rate
$438.11
cheaper over the whole loan, down payment included
| Rebate | Low rate | |
|---|---|---|
| You borrow | $24,500 | $27,000 |
| Monthly payment | $479.37 | $472.07 |
| Interest | $4,262.26 | $1,324.15 |
| Total cost of the car | $31,762.26 | $31,324.15 |
- Rebate that would make them equal
- $2,873.18
- Highest low rate that still wins
- 2.516%
Low-rate offers are often limited to buyers with the best credit and may need a shorter term. Get a quote from your own bank or credit union first, and put its rate in the box.
A choice that is easy to get wrong
Car makers often offer two deals on the same car, and you can take only one:
- Cash back. A rebate comes off the price. You finance the rest, at the rate your own bank or credit union offers.
- A low rate. No rebate, but the maker’s finance arm lends the full amount at a promotional rate, sometimes 0%.
The low rate feels like the bigger prize. Sometimes it is. Sometimes the rebate is worth more. The only way to know is to add up what each costs over the whole loan, and that is what this page does.
What the two options look like
A $30,000 car, $3,000 down, a 60-month loan. Option A is a $2,500 rebate with a loan at 6.5% from your bank. Option B is 1.9% with no rebate.
| Cash back | Low rate | |
|---|---|---|
| You borrow | $24,500 | $27,000 |
| Monthly payment | $479.37 | $472.07 |
| Interest | $4,262.26 | $1,324.15 |
| Paid on the loan | $28,762.26 | $28,324.15 |
| Total cost of the car | $31,762.26 | $31,324.15 |
The total cost includes the $3,000 down payment, which is the same in both. The low rate wins by $438.11.
Look at the monthly payments: they are close, $7.30 apart. The comparison is not obvious from the payment alone, which is why dealers like to quote it.
When the rebate wins
Change the numbers and the answer flips. A $5,000 rebate with a 7% bank loan, over 48 months, against 0.9% with no rebate:
| Cash back | Low rate | |
|---|---|---|
| You borrow | $22,000 | $27,000 |
| Monthly payment | $526.82 | $572.90 |
| Interest | $3,287.19 | $499.07 |
The rebate costs $2,211.88 less in total, even though the low rate has far less interest. The reason is the size of the rebate: $5,000 off the price is more than the interest the low rate saves. A bigger rebate, a shorter loan, or a low rate that is not that low, all favour the rebate.
The two break-evens
The page works out where the decision flips, so you can judge how close it is.
The rebate that would make them equal. In the first example the rebate is $2,500, and it would need to be $2,873.18 to match the 1.9% offer: $373.18 more. If you can negotiate the rebate up by that much, take it.
The highest low rate that still wins. The first example’s low rate could be as high as 2.516% and still beat the rebate. Above that, the rebate is better. If the dealer’s offer is 1.9%, you are comfortably inside it; if it is 3%, the rebate wins.
Why your bank’s rate matters
The rebate option depends on the rate you can get elsewhere. The higher your bank’s rate, the more the rebate loses its value, because you pay more interest on the loan the rebate leaves. So the CFPB suggests getting a quote from a bank or credit union before you shop, to have something to compare the dealer’s offers with. Enter that rate, not a guess.
The catches
The CFPB makes three points about low-rate offers:
- Only some buyers qualify. Only buyers with the highest credit scores get 0% financing.
- There may be other conditions, such as paying the loan off quickly. A shorter term raises the payment.
- They may apply only to certain models.
If the low rate comes with a shorter term, set the term here to match, and compare the totals. A shorter loan has less interest, but the payment is higher, so check you can afford it.
Two other things to check
- Sales tax. In some places tax is charged on the price before the rebate, which makes the rebate option costlier than it looks. Check how yours works.
- Fees. Compare the total price, not just the headline offer. The CFPB’s auto loan shopping sheet is a useful worksheet for comparing loans.
For the cost of a car loan without a choice to make, see the auto loan calculator. In the UK, the car loan calculator compares HP and PCP. To see what a rate really means once fees are counted, use the APR calculator.
What this does not include
- Trade-in, sales tax and fees. Add them to the price you enter if they apply.
- Early repayment. If you will pay the loan off early, interest saved is smaller than shown.
- Credit approval. The offer you are shown may not be the one you get.
How it is calculated
Option A borrows the price less the down payment and the rebate, at your bank’s rate. Option B borrows the price less the down payment, at the low rate. Each payment is B × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)⁻ⁿ), rounded to the cent, with the interest each month rounded to the cent and the last payment clearing the balance. The total cost is the down payment plus every payment. The break-evens are found by trying amounts, to the cent for the rebate and to 0.001% for the rate. Amounts are exact decimals.
Frequently asked questions
Should I take the cash rebate or the low interest rate?
Compare the total cost of each. On a $30,000 car with $3,000 down over 60 months, a $2,500 rebate with a 6.5% bank loan costs $31,762.26 in all, and a 1.9% loan with no rebate costs $31,324.15. The low rate wins by $438.11. On other numbers the rebate wins.
When does the rebate win?
When it is large, the loan is short, or the low rate is not very low. A $5,000 rebate with a 7% loan over 48 months beats 0.9% with no rebate by $2,211.88. The calculator also shows the rebate that would make the two equal.
Why does the rebate reduce the loan?
Because the rebate comes off the price, so you borrow less. On the first example you borrow $24,500 with the rebate and $27,000 without. That saves interest as well as the rebate itself.
Can everyone get the 0% or low-rate offer?
No. The CFPB notes that only buyers with the highest credit scores qualify for 0% financing, and that such offers may come with other requirements, such as paying the loan off quickly, or apply only to certain models. Read the fine print.
What bank rate should I enter?
A real quote. The CFPB suggests getting a loan offer from a bank or credit union before you shop, so you have something to compare the dealer's offers with. Use that rate for the rebate option.
What does this leave out?
Sales tax, which some places charge before the rebate and some after, fees, a trade-in, and a shorter term that may come with the low rate. Add any of those to the price or the terms you enter, and compare the total.
Related calculators
- Auto Loan CalculatorEnter the price, your down payment and trade-in, and the loan terms.
- Car Loan CalculatorEnter the price, your deposit, the APR and the term.
- Loan / EMI CalculatorEnter the amount, the rate and the term.
- APR CalculatorThe rate on the note is not what the loan costs.
- Interest Rate CalculatorEnter what you borrowed, what you pay each month and for how long.
- Auto Lease CalculatorA lease pays for the depreciation, not the car.
- Personal Loan CalculatorEnter how much you need, the rate, the fee and the term.
- Loan Payoff CalculatorEnter what you still owe, the rate and the months left.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: how do I qualify for an advertised 0% auto financing
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: auto loan shopping sheet: comparing auto loans
This tool is for information only and is not financial advice. Figures are estimates, confirm anything you act on with your lender or a qualified adviser.